Monday, April 20, 2009

There should be a debate between Top (Shia and Suni) Scholers and scholers from Sawat on the issues going on these days.....

It should be a good idea to , bring the top scholers(Shia , Suni) and scholers from swat to a forum (live on any tv channel) where they can discuss things openly in front of nation and try to solve things through dialouges?
Or atleast try to prove their point in front of whole nation.

Nation should know that who is rite and who is wrong so that they can openly support them.Please commen on this.

8 comments:

  1. :) let see i never found any Muslim scholars solving any issues :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well I am talking about sensiour and authenticated/qualified Scholars like Mufi Muneeb-ur-rehma , Dr Israr , Someone from Tableeghi jamat , Ghamdi shb and there are many more.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Just to update this blog I will post the comment (on facebook) of a respectable colleague of mine "Mehdi shb", he said.

    Sir Dr. Israr to aayen gay naheen Shia Ulema kay saamnay - there is a little history to that ...

    Ghamdi Sahib aur Muneeb ur Rehman sahib khaasay samajhdaar log hain - woh is chakkar main shayed hee parrain .. its too dangerous ..

    Reh gaye tableeghi jamaat waalay - to woh aa bhee jaayen to apnay ilaawa kisee kee sunnnay kee aadat naheen hotee un ko ...... Read More

    So i guess you should drop this idea .... just duaa karrain ALLAH behter karray gaa ....

    ReplyDelete
  4. and my response to above post "on facebook was".

    hmmm ....Yehi soch hum main sa bohot sara logon ki thi sir ...ka do politicle parties ka log kabhi bhi aik forum pa baith ka discussion nahin kar sakta....But efforts have made it possible...Agar baat mulk ki salamti ko ho to sab aik baat pa mutafiq ho jata hain , and we have scene those example in past.
    So why not , I mean Is there any reason that... Read More we shouldn't convince them to forget about the coflicts they have between them and just for the sake of this country/nation they should sit on a table and try to resolve things......Everything is possible ,, we just need to try for that and yes you are rite we should always pray ALLAH for the bettermment ......
    Well in my openion If the scholars are agreed on one point regarding this issue they have very good communities and their message will be covyed very easily and people will be more convinced.

    ReplyDelete
  5. In this metter Scholars can play an effective role.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yes I agree with you. Infect right now its not problem of shia and sunee. At least sunee people which are around 80% of Pakistan population should have consensus on said issue.
    I believe right now this is responsibility of all of us to play our role specially our religious scholars and ulmaeikram.
    We have to have solution of this problem right now otherwise we will pay allot like our past. I am very positive and hope so we will be able to find out a better solution.

    ReplyDelete
  7. look at this.
    http://www.express.com.pk/epaper/PoPupwindow.aspx?newsID=1100611819&Issue=NP_LHE&Date=20090426

    ReplyDelete
  8. It would have been much better that our governmet had annouced this session on national level and Ulmas like Dr Israr , some one from tableeghi jamat , Ghamdi shb and other most famous Scholars had joined it, and that session had been covered by all media channels to show our nationa what our ulmas are saying about this misshappning these day.
    Still MASHALLAH I can see this is a very gppd effort May ALLAh bless Shebaz Sharif a long life to server the nation AMIN.

    ReplyDelete